To view this page ensure that Adobe Flash Player version 11.1.0 or greater is installed.
Page 22 THE VILLADOM TIMES I & III • January 29, 2014
Joaquin Phoenix stars in odd romantic comedy
by Dennis Seuling
“Her” is an odd romantic comedy set in Los Angeles
in the near future. Theodore (Joaquin Phoenix) works
for a company called beautifulhandwrittenletters.com
composing intimate letters and notes of love, desire,
loss, and other heartfelt emotions for people who are too
busy to express their thoughts themselves. Ironically, no
hand ever touches a pen. The letters are composed on the
computer in script.
Though he is very good at pouring out Hallmark card-
style expressions at work, Theodore has trouble with his
own relationships. His wife, Catherine (Rooney Mara),
has left him and Theodore is pretty much alone until he
buys a new operating system for his computer with built-
in artificial intelligence: a disembodied voice (Scarlett
Johansson) called Samantha.
Samantha initially helps organize Theodore’s online
files and reminds him of appointments, but soon picks
up emotions in Theodore’s voice and senses his moods.
Turning into a sort of in-home therapist, she begins to
have conversations with him. She offers opinions, asks
questions, and takes a personal interest in Theodore.
Director Spike Jonze has combined romantic comedy/
drama with science fiction to come up with one of the
most original and strangest movies in a long time. Visu-
ally, he provides an ultra-modern Los Angeles (Shanghai
stands in for L.A.) where people walk around with their
heads buried in portable tech devices -- an apt metaphor
for a detached society.
Phoenix is an interesting choice as the lead. Were he
an A-list star, he might have trouble selling his character.
Audiences know his face from his body of work, but he
comes off as one of the crowd -- a guy who does his job
each day, then has to face an evening with little to do and
no one with whom to share his life. Because his life is
devoid of any real relationship, he bonds with Samantha,
surprised at her ability to learn quickly, access informa-
tion in milliseconds, and display a sense of humor. Theo-
dore becomes so obsessed with Samantha that he carries
a small camera so she can see moment to moment what
he is doing. In this future, a simple earpiece is all it takes
to get online, so Samantha is there whenever he wants
her. Phoenix plays the reclusive Theodore with just the
right amount of awkwardness, so viewers understand
when he opens up to Samantha.
Once the film’s setting is established and viewers see
Theodore’s sad life, it’s easy to accept that he responds
to Samantha’s human-like qualities. He is in a “relation-
ship” without the responsibilities a human-to-human
bond entails. Samantha is there at his convenience and
for his convenience. He likes this arrangement and the
relationship develops in odd ways.
Johansson does an amazing job with only a vocal
performance, and listening to her throaty, warm voice,
one can see why Theodore regards Samantha as more
than a mere operating system. Her delicate performance
makes believable the intimacy of the relationship that
develops. Amy Adams appears as Amy, Theodore’s neighbor.
They meet in the elevator on the way to or from work
and exchange pleasantries. This is the only real human-
to-human relationship Theodore has. Eventually, the
two become arm’s-length confidantes and discuss their
lives with cool objectivity. Only when a crisis arises do
they connect in more than a superficial manner.
Science fiction movies often underplay ideas in favor
of special effects. In “Her,” director Jonze makes his Los
Angeles look just different enough that one accepts it as
the future. He avoids gadgetry, even though the premise
of the movie relies on technology. His theme of human
detachment is what keeps the audience involved. Once
Joaquin Phoenix plays Theodore, a man who has difficulty
making human connections, in ‘Her.’
the story kicks in, viewers become immersed in its
quirkiness and unpredictability.
Rated R, “Her” is an audacious, brave romantic
comedy that defies whatever one might think a movie
romance should be. Jonze points his lens at human
frailty, the need for connection, and one’s desperation
to achieve it. Not since HAL stole the film in “2001:
A Space Odyssey” has a computer been a full-fledged
character with a vocal performance so perfect, so mem-
orable, and ultimately so unsettling.