To view this page ensure that Adobe Flash Player version 11.1.0 or greater is installed.
Page 22 THE VILLADOM TIMES III • December 11, 2013
Maybe we need Sherlock Holmes
Trying to enjoy some early slumber one night, I was
alerted by the patter -- actually more like the thunder -- of
two pairs of little feet on the staircase.
“Dad! Dad! We just discovered a detective show where
the detective solves cases by using his brains instead of
beating people up!”
“What is the name of this newly discovered detective?”
I asked suspiciously.
“Sherlock Holmes!”
“I think I may have heard of him.”
Despite my torpor, I was elated that the kids had discov-
ered the “new” Sherlock Holmes -- Jeremy Brett, in this
case -- because I knew they would watch his adventures
voluntarily. If Holmes had been forced on them, they would
have done anything in their power, including times tables
drills or piano lessons, to resist watching the shows. My
logic worked. They became Sherlock Holmes buffs.
Holmes seldom made mistakes, but people make mis-
takes about Holmes. As portrayed on the screen by every-
one from the classic Basil Rathbone with Nigel Bruce, to
the Hammer Productions Peter Cushing, aided and abetted
by his best friend Christopher Lee, to Jeremy Brett with
David Burke as Watson -- they each sent my kids an auto-
graphed photograph in response to a fan letter.
Some think Holmes is the archetypal stiff-upper-lip
Englishman, representing a class-conscious society. That
is wrong. Arthur Conan Doyle was Irish, and the real-life
characters who inspired Holmes was a Scot, Dr. Joseph
Bell, who had been Doyle’s professor in medical school,
and taught him how to analyze appearances while making
medical deductions.
While Holmes is generally shown as imperturbable,
Doyle was subject to enormous inner turbulence. Raised as
a devout Catholic, Doyle lapsed into disbelief, then into a
sort of eclecticism, and finally into spiritualism, which he
famously championed in ways that were more emotional
than logical. Yet improved research into the paranormal
indicates that Doyle was not on ground as shaky as some of
his critics asserted.
Doyle, above all, was a humanitarian and, in a racist era,
he believed, as Henry Wadsworth Longfellow wrote three
times in “The Song of Hiawatha,” that “Every human heart
is human.” One of his least-read books today is “The Crime
of the Congo,” in which Doyle documented Belgian atroci-
ties against the Bantu and Pygmy peoples of sub-Saharan
Africa with photographs that can still raise a shudder after a
century. Holmes wrote the 45,000-word book in eight days
and it influenced dignitaries including Winston Churchill,
Kaiser Wilhelm II, and Theodore Roosevelt -- all of whom
were good friends and mutual admirers at the time -- to
protest against the grisly Belgian inhumanity toward the
Africans. Doyle got most of his information from Sir Roger Case-
ment, later sentenced to death for his role in Irish indepen-
dence, and Doyle, respecting Casement’s humanitarian
work in the Congo and in South America, headed the move-
ment to spare Casement the death penalty for “treason,”
by which the British meant support for Irish independence
in wartime. The British hanged Casement in spite of the
appeals led by Doyle.
Doyle had no patience with either male chauvinism or
class snobbery. The only woman to outwit Sherlock Holmes,
in Doyle’s first magazine story, “A Scandal in Bohemia,” is
Irene Adler. Adler trumps Holmes’ trickery and mastery of
disguise, knocks his metaphorical block off, and comes out
the winner in the case, sending Holmes a condescending
farewell note.
In a subsequent story, the mystery revolves around a
white American woman’s attempt to hide the fact that her
child by a first marriage, living with her in England, is of
mixed African ancestry. “(A) nobler man never walked the
earth,” the widow says of her first husband, a black man
since deceased. In the end, the woman’s second husband
kisses and accepts the child as his own.
In another story, the presumed villains in the strange
behavior of a white man presumed to be an opium addict
are a “lascar” -- a lower-caste Hindu -- and a Chinese man.
Neither is a bad guy when the case is cleared up. I will not
ruin it for the reader. The white guy finds out he can make
more money as a street beggar than as a journalist. That
ruined it for me. I chose to forget the title.
Doyle was not an expert on the British Empire as Rud-
yard Kipling, the other most popular British officer of the
era was, since Kipling grew up there and returned as a
young man. In “The Sign of the Four,” Doyle offers a sinis-
ter but reliable Sikh with the name “Mahomet Singh.” The
last name “Singh” is given to every Sikh man. “Mahomet”
-- Muhammad -- is an impossible name for a Sikh. The
Sikhs organized to keep the Muslims out of central India
about 500 years ago and most definitely did not name their
sons after Muhammad.
I once knew a Jewish man whom everybody called by a
rather cute first name. I asked his wife about it. The man’s
given name was Adolf. He never used it. The same prin-
ciple applies.
Two of Doyle’s private cases -- not as the author of
Sherlock Holmes but as an expert witness -- also revolved
around opposition to prejudice. A mixed-blood Indian man
named George Edalji had been sentenced to seven years
in prison due to maiming horses -- a particularly disgust-
ing crime in which the perpetrators harmed animals to take
some sort of revenge on the owners. Edalji was convicted
against circumstantial evidence. He had alibis and one of
the incidents took place while he was in jail. While inter-
viewing Edalji, Doyle learned that the accused night stalker
was virtually blind and could not have located, let alone
mutilated, the livestock on moonless nights. He also found
other flaws in the evidence. Edjali was released from jail,
but was not formally cleared for 20 years.
In another case, a gambler and pawnbroker named Oscar
Slater was accused of bludgeoning and robbing an elderly
widow. He was caught after he attempted to pawn a dia-
mond brooch. The culprit, being both Jewish and an immi-
grant from Germany, was convicted despite the fact that the
brooch he tried to pawn had never belonged to the victim
and that the police in the case had reportedly prompted the
housemaid who said she had seen him near the scene of the
crime. Slater’s common-law wife had an alibi for him but
was not allowed to testify because they were not legally
married. Slater spent 17 years in jail. Doyle got into the
case and Slater was released with 6,000 pounds compensa-
tion for time spent in prison. He thanked Doyle profusely,
but later stiffed Doyle for legal costs.
Toward the end of his life, Doyle was taken in by
“Margery the Medium,” Minna Crandon of Boston, who
bamboozled a number of Harvard professors with séance
phenomena that were simple tricks. A “spirit” thumbprint
she produced in dental wax in a blacked-out room turned
out to be -- the thumbprint of her own dentist. Doyle took
out a full-page newspaper ad attacking Dr. Joseph Banks
Rhine, who had realized after one sitting that Margery was
a fake and the elderly professors were romantic dupes.
Dr. Rhine later went on to show, after 40 years of
exacting research at Duke University, that mind-to-mind
communication between the living was a statistically dem-
onstrated reality.
Doyle had the wrong perpetrator, but his defense of
people who were unjustly accused of crimes due to race or
religion was definitely on the right track. Perhaps we can
convince the schools to make some of his stories required
reading. Ho-Ho-Kus Jottings
Have Breakfast with Santa
The Contemporary Club of Ho-Ho-Kus will host its
annual Breakfast with Santa on Saturday, Dec. 14. The
event will be held from 10 to 11:30 a.m. in the multi-pur-
pose room of the Ho-Ho-Kus Public School located at 70
Lloyd Road. The event will feature arts & crafts, musical
entertainment by “Big Jeff,” and a visit from Santa.
Tickets are $10 per person. For tickets and information,
contact Shannon at semcg159@yahoo.com. Seating is lim-
ited. Attendees are asked to bring a non-perishable food
item to support the club’s Food Drive to benefit families
in need.
Council to host single meeting
The Ho-Ho-Kus Council will hold just one meet-
ing during the month of December. The 8 p.m. session is
scheduled for Tuesday, Dec. 17 at borough hall, 333 Warren
Avenue. Library board plans meeting
The Worth-Pinkham Memorial Library Board of Trust-
ees will meet on Monday, Dec. 16 at 7:30 p.m. The public is
welcome. The meeting will be held at the library, 91 Warren
Avenue in Ho-Ho-Kus.
Hermitage sets Champagne & Candlelight
Friends of the Hermitage will host its annual Cham-
pagne and Candlelight evening on Friday, Dec. 13 from 6
to 9 p.m. The evening will begin inside the historic Hermit-
age, 335 North Franklin Turnpike in Ho-Ho-Kus, with a
champagne toast. The reception in Jacqua Hall will include
wine, punch, and hors d’oeuvres. Guests will enjoy live
music by the Bill Thoman Jazz Trio, have an opportunity
to view a display of Rosencrantz Christmas ornaments, and
bid on auction items. The choir of Saint Luke’s Church in
Ho-Ho-Kus will welcome visitors by singing carols on the
porch of the Hermitage from 6:30 to 7:30 p.m.
This year’s theme for the decor is “Song & Verse: Christ-
mas with the Rosencrantzes,” inspired by the Hermitage’s
Rosencrantz family collection of sheet music and books.
Festive dresses of the Victorian period from the Friends’
collection will be displayed. Holiday songs, poems, and
stories cherished by three generations of the Rosencrantz
family will be featured on decorated trees, wreaths, and
mantles. Tickets for this opportunity to enjoy the museum during
the evening are available by advance reservation online at
www.thehermitage.org or by calling the museum office at
(201) 445-8311, extension 36. The cost is $60 per person.
After Dec. 6, tickets will be $70. Proceeds from this fund-
raiser will benefit children’s educational programs at The
Hermitage. This National Historic Landmark is one of the
nation’s outstanding examples of domestic Gothic Revival
architecture. The Friends of the Hermitage, Inc., a non-profit mem-
bership organization, manages the Hermitage, a New
Jersey State Park. The Friends received a general operating
support grant from the New Jersey Historical Commission,
a division of Cultural Affairs in the Department of State.
Library announces new hours, classes
The Worth-Pinkham Memorial Library, located at
91 Warren Avenue in Ho-Ho-Kus, will expand its hours
beginning Jan. 2, 2014. The library will be open Monday,
Wednesday, and Friday from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m.; Tuesday
and Thursday from 10 a.m. to 8 p.m.; and Saturdays from
10 a.m. to 1 p.m.
The library will host free knitting classes with Sally
Anne in January. The eight-week free class will begin Jan.
6 at 7 p.m. Registration is required, space is limited.
The English as a Second Language Conversation Group
will meet on Thursdays beginning Jan. 9. The one-hour
sessions are open to all who wish to practice their English
in an informal venue. The program will run through March
13. Registration is required.
Call (201) 327-4338 to register for classes or for addi-
tional information.