Page 16 THE VILLADOM TIMES IV • December 1, 2010 became successful farmers. (Twiss was so disgusted that he formalized his marriage to a Lakota woman and now has about 400 descendants on Pine Ridge, all of whom will tell you Twiss was second in his class at West Point and Custer was dead last.) In 1868, after a bloody defeat in Red Cloud’s War, Congress gave the Sioux reservations that the United States was sworn to protect. That treaty lasted about five years, until the government got tired of it. On the Yellowstone in 1873, Sitting Bull and the Lakota, who were protecting their hunting grounds, fought Custer, who was protecting the stock he owned in the Northern Pacific Railroad. The battle was a draw, but the railroad collapsed due to the Depression of 1873, Custer lost money, and the Lakota got to keep their hunting grounds for a few more years. Sitting Bull didn’t care whom he offended. He once sent a Lakota woman out to rail at a bunch of peace commissioners, and pardon him for not being PC, but having a woman dis you in public was the ultimate insult in his culture. He made a speech at another summit meeting, where what he said was: “I hate all you Americans. You are all thieves and liars. You have stolen everything we had and left us beggars. We spit on you.” The Indian who was interpreting somehow translated this as: “Come my brothers, let us have peace. Let us see what kind of a world we can make for our children.” Something got lost in translation. Sitting Bull was astounded when he got a huge round of applause, so much that he was taken on a regular speaking tour. Then he ran into Buffalo Bill Cody, who sensed his ability to draw a crowd and took him on into Buffalo Bill’s Wild West Show. Sitting Bull learned to write his signature – augmented with a sketch of a squatting bison for people who couldn’t read cursive – and he made a lot of money selling autographs. Ragged white children sensed a soft touch and used to cluster around him when he spent his money buying hot dogs, peanuts, and popcorn for his entourage of laughing children, who acknowledged him as their chieftain while he slipped them snacks. Handing out autographs, he would say “Sitting Bull – you bet!” and slip the money to the white urchins. He was a great friend of Annie Oakley, the petite sharpshooter who grew up deathly poor and was American’s sweetheart in the days before movies. He found Cody tolerable, but thought he drank too much. Some of the Lakota voyaged to England and met Queen Victoria, the Kaiser, and the Pope, all of whom they liked a great deal. They found the costumes of the Swiss Guards hilarious. When the word got back to Sitting Bull, he sent a prime buffalo robe and a friendly letter to the Pope. Sitting Bull already knew some French that he had learned from fur trader, and he now had a traveling artist named Rudolph Cronau swap lessons with him: Lakota for German. Sitting Bull didn’t hate whites. He hated the United States. He refused to speak English because he said it was snake talk: a language for liars. In 1887, Sitting Bull led the opposition to signing away a large portion of the land left over from the Sioux Treaty of 1868, which had never been legally abrogated. When the self-styled “friends of the Indian” presented their petitions to Grover Cleveland, the Beast of Buffalo told them they didn’t have enough signatures and told them to get out of his office. Grover Cleveland refused to annex Hawaii under similar circumstances. The next president was more pliable. The Sioux lost another huge swath of land and their parched reservation leftovers were broken up into 160-acre tracts too small for grazing and too dry for farming without expensive irrigation. Finally, the Indians all over the West began trance-dancing to see their lost loved ones. One of their terrified Indian Agents, a failed physician and newsman, saw this as threatening and called for troops. Half the U.S. Army converged on the Sioux reservations. Sitting Bull was not a believer in the Ghost Dance, but his Indian Agent – a rival for the respect of the people on the reservation – ordered his arrest. Sitting Bull was either deliberately murdered or killed in the scuffle by Indians in government pay, which was the customary death for leaders of the Indian resistance. Of all the great Indian leaders, only Tecumseh was killed by whites. Murder by proxy is murder all the same. Was Sitting Bull a real American? Of the 268 soldiers killed at the Little Bighorn, 106 were born in Ireland and 100 were born in Germany, with others born in Britain, Canada, and Denmark. Where was Sitting Bull born? America. Was Sitting Bull a hero? You bet. He lived for his people and died violently because he wouldn’t sell out. Was Obama right to put him on the list? Yes. Was Fox News vicious – perhaps rabid – to take another nip at a man who inherited most of the economic mess we’re in from his Republican predecessor’s pointless war and the last Democratic president’s support of easy credit for unqualified borrowers and massive outsourcing? Half of the dislike for Obama seems racially motivated, which is unacceptable to decent people, and the other half seems to focus on the fact that he can’t fulfill the expectations of people who expect him to bring back the Cold War economy without the threat of nuclear destruction. Don’t let the Fox bite Obama -- and remember that Sitting Bull was a real American. The rest of us are still working on it. I recently saved a small part of America from a fox. The beast was roaming around an occupied area and I made such a nuisance of myself trying to take its photograph that it voluntarily moved to a different town. Don’t harm this fox; it may yet achieve mascot status if it doesn’t get hit by the increasingly rude drivers. Personally I’d rather have more foxes and fewer taxes. Now it’s time to save American from the fox that took a nip at President Obama for mentioning Sitting Bull, a collateral friend of the family, along with such luminaries as George Washington and Helen Keller in his new children’s book, “Of Thee I Sing.” Obama tells us that Sitting Bull was a medicine man who healed “broken hearts and broken promises” but that he is “most famous for his stunning victory in 1876 over Lieutenant Colonel George Armstrong Custer in the Battle of the Little Bighorn.” Fox News struck back: “Obama Praises Indian Chief Who Killed U.S. General.” Now for the facts: Sitting Bull didn’t kill George Armstrong Custer, who was, as Obama correctly said, a lieutenant colonel at the time of his death commanding five companies of the Seventh Cavalry. Sitting Bull didn’t even fight at the Little Bighorn – not because he was “too old,” as one historian said. Sitting Bull was 42 at the time of the Little Bighorn, living with his mother, four wives, and a bunch of his kids. He didn’t fight because he had just offered 100 pieces of flesh cut out of both arms at a sun dance ceremony and was probably still too feeble from loss of blood to be much good in a fight. Sitting Bull had struck 68 enemy Indians in battle, sometimes fatally, sometimes just for laughs, before the wars against the whites took off. He once offered a surrounded Crow warrior a shot at him with his own musket, took a hit in the foot, jumped off his horse, limped over to the defiant Crow and stabbed him to death. You would not have wanted to offend this man. Sitting Bull was no coward. He grew up in tough times, when the U.S. War Department had ordered the destruction of the Lakota, or Sioux. “We must proceed with vindictive earnestness to the utter extermination of the Sioux Nation: men, women, and children,” said General William Tecumseh Sherman. The much-maligned President Ulysses S. Grant would not go for it, and the Sioux got broken treaties and short rations instead of genocide. Only some of the men, women, and children were murdered. Most later died of complications of malnutrition or contagious diseases. One historian who deplored Fox News as inaccurate but saw Sitting Bull as overrated, claimed that Sitting Bull was an arch-conservative who was fighting for an outmoded way of life hunting buffalo and roaming the prairies. That’s dead wrong. Thomas Twiss, second in his class at West Point and the first agent to the Oglala Sioux, got the Sioux, the Cheyenne, and the Arapaho to accept designated reservations in 1860, before the bloodiest of the Plains Indian Wars had been fought. Congress couldn’t afford the annuities Twiss recommended until the Indians Sitting Bull and Obama attacked by vicious Fox Letters to the Editor Dear Editor: I’m appalled that three years after the Mahwah community expressed its strong objections to the Crossroads development proposal, our council is once again considering this monstrosity. Three years ago, I was one of 80 residents who attended the series of public hearings to strongly oppose the plan. Apparently, our concerns and objections fell on deaf ears. Developing this site into a shopping mall complete with stores, restaurants, and movie theaters will turn the current Route 17 traffic mess into a crawling nightmare! It will not only draw on area shoppers, but will attract New Yorkers looking for tax-free clothes shopping. New Yorkers will be coming from the north, traveling south on the Thruway, and from the east, traveling west from the Tappan Zee Bridge. Can Route 17 handle that kind of additional traffic? Absolutely not -- even with the proposed so-called “traffic improvements.” For those of you who use Route 17 to commute to work, imagine what it will be like when the multi-theater movie complex lets out at rush hour. Think of what getting home from work will be like during the Christmas shopping season. And we all know what Route 17 is like on a Friday evening during the summer! Because traffic is now down to a crawl, you’re going to see drivers diverting on to the side roads. If you live near Route 17, you had better hunker down, because your quiet little neighborhood is going to turn into a freeway. And, don’t forget to consider what it’s going to be like during the couple of years while these roads are being constructed: Think traffic diversions, and lane and road closures. Are we having fun yet? With a mall comes crime. That will mean a larger police Opposes new development force. Guess who’s going to have to pay for that. And, don’t think these pickpockets and thieves will only prey on the mall. While they’re here, they will have discovered a whole new community to burglarize. What about emergencies? Can our volunteer fire and ambulance departments handle a mall? The proposed Crossroads development is nothing but a losing situation. It will cripple Route 17, attract crime, and raise our taxes. Do you really want Mahwah to turn into another Paramus? Chris Maurer Mahwah Dear Editor: Thank you to all the wonderful people who spent their time in helping make sure this year’s Ziti Dinner was a huge success. From the start, it was a tough year financially with so many businesses cutting back, but what a phenomenal finish we had! We served over 400 dinners. There is no way we would have been able to have had a successful fundraiser without everyone who volunteered. Thank you to all our DARE Room Parents from Dater School and Saint Paul’s School. Thank you to everyone who came out on Friday and Saturday and stayed on just to give an extra hand. Thank you to those who were flexible when you were grabbed from one section and placed somewhere else to help. Thank you to those who stayed on until the very end helping to wash the floor, put back the tables, and bring supplies back to police headquarters. Thank you all our bakers who donated all the delicious desserts. A huge thank you goes out to all the dads who started helping Friday night and didn’t stop until Saturday night. (continued on page 14) Dinner organizers express thanks